• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

Gagner/Hemsky?

Chev-boyar-sky

New member
Just throwing out a couple names on the Oilers that I like and think are realistic trade targets.

Not sure they fit the style/mold/needs of the team but I'm interested to see what people think...

The Oilers need D-men, size, and defensively responsible forwards. I think we are a good potential trading partner. If we could move any of Grabbo/Mac/Gunnar/AHL guys playing over their heads/Liles/certain prospects I'd be up for it.

Gagner would be a better #1 than Bozak, would be dynamite on the PP and could be the #2 when we get a real #1. Hemsky I'm less interested in but has boatloads of speed/talent but is injury prone.

Lines of could be interesting:

Lupul - Gagner - Kessel
JVR - Bozak - Hemsky
Frattin - Kadri - Kulemin
Orr - Mclement - Komarov

We lose a little defensive mindedness in the trade, but add the potential to score a ton on the PP (not unlike Tampa).

And now you can all cut me to pieces....

 
Chev-boyar-sky said:
Just throwing out a couple names on the Oilers that I like and think are realistic trade targets.

Not sure they fit the style/mold/needs of the team but I'm interested to see what people think...

The Oilers need D-men, size, and defensively responsible forwards. I think we are a good potential trading partner. If we could move any of Grabbo/Mac/Gunnar/AHL guys playing over their heads/Liles/certain prospects I'd be up for it.

Gagner would be a better #1 than Bozak, would be dynamite on the PP and could be the #2 when we get a real #1. Hemsky I'm less interested in but has boatloads of speed/talent but is injury prone.

Lines of could be interesting:

Lupul - Gagner - Kessel
JVR - Bozak - Hemsky
Frattin - Kadri - Kulemin
Orr - Mclement - Komarov

We lose a little defensive mindedness in the trade, but add the potential to score a ton on the PP (not unlike Tampa).

And now you can all cut me to pieces....

The most intriguing line there is made up of players we already have...

Frattin - Kadri - Kulemin

I like Gagner too, but I would expect the Oilers to demand a LOT for him.

 
I don't think that either guy is a bad target for a trade but I think if there's something that we've seen recently with the JvR trade it's that if you're going to try and land a good young player the likelihood is that the other team is going to want a good young player in return. Building a trade like this around the Leafs only getting rid of guys who they're a little disappointed with/would have no problem letting go doesn't really seem like much of a deal for the Oilers.

 
Chev-boyar-sky said:
Just throwing out a couple names on the Oilers that I like and think are realistic trade targets.

Not sure they fit the style/mold/needs of the team but I'm interested to see what people think...

The Oilers need D-men, size, and defensively responsible forwards. I think we are a good potential trading partner. If we could move any of Grabbo/Mac/Gunnar/AHL guys playing over their heads/Liles/certain prospects I'd be up for it.

Gagner would be a better #1 than Bozak, would be dynamite on the PP and could be the #2 when we get a real #1. Hemsky I'm less interested in but has boatloads of speed/talent but is injury prone.

Lines of could be interesting:

Lupul - Gagner - Kessel
JVR - Bozak - Hemsky
Frattin - Kadri - Kulemin
Orr - Mclement - Komarov

We lose a little defensive mindedness in the trade, but add the potential to score a ton on the PP (not unlike Tampa).

And now you can all cut me to pieces....
Like Hemky's skills, don't like his durability.  As he approaches 30 I don't expect it to get better.  I run hot and cold on Gagner.  Without delving into advanced stats, my perception from watching them both play is that he's not a marked upgrade on Grabovski. 

If there's a thought he could be converted to a decent center, push for Taylor Hall.  Start with Gardiner and build a trade package.
 
Back
Top